YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

    Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

    To get started, first
    Puck Daddy

    Dean Lombardi explains why the Kings/Blue Jackets clock controversy isn’t intentional cheating

    138065766GM Scott Howson has openly questioned if the clock freezing at 1.8 seconds in the  Columbus Blue Jackets' loss at the Los Angeles Kings on Wednesday night was "either a deliberate stopping of the clock or the clock malfunctioned."

    GM Dean Lombardi of the Los Angeles Kings has answered: Neither one, actually.

    From the Los Angeles Times, here's the explanation Lombardi emailed out:

    "Those clocks are sophisticated instruments that calculate time by measuring electrical charges called coulombs — given the rapidity and volume of electrons that move through the measuring device the calibrator must adjust at certain points which was the delay you see. The delay is just recalibrating for the clock moving too quickly during the 10—10ths of a second before the delay. This insures that the actual playing time during a period is exactly 20 minutes.

    "That is not an opinion -— that is science -— amazing device quite frankly."

    Although the clock didn't last night, Lombardi's response syncs up with that of PD reader Christian Turner:

    "The clock stoppage is actually common, just not always in the last seconds of a game leading to a GWG in that final second. It is the clock's display syncing with the internal clock/computer."

    So there you go.

    Also, regarding the idea — OK, our idea — that the last few seconds and the eventual overtime should be replayed on March 8 before the Kings/Blue Jackets game, a devil's advocate response we were given: Would the teams be required to dress the game teams that played last night? Do trade deadline acquisitions sit? Do trade deadline departures come back?

    Valid points that nonetheless ruin our fun.

     

    45 comments

    • Bettman Blows  •  Huntsville, Alabama  •  3 months ago
      "The clock stoppage is actually common"
      We can test this:
      -we saw 5 seconds of a 60 minute game (0.14%)
      -if a clock stoppage happens randomly once a game, then with 1230 games in a season then the clock should stop twice per year during the final 5 seconds.
      -of course, how many games go to replay in the dying seconds when we are actually watching the clock? maybe 10 at most? in this case the clock stoppage would only be observed once every 75 years. Which about as often as Gomez scores.
    • pnkwag  •  Mt Hamilton, California  •  3 months ago
      tbh, i've noticed this phenomenon before in non-Kings games, it happens periodically, just coincidence that this happened in the last seconds of a game and a goal occurred.

      and fyi, i'm not a kings fan.
      • Christian 3 months ago
        I am a Kings fan and I too have seen this in other events. It's needs to be investigated just to be sure and then it needs to be explained so there is no confusion.
    • Ross  •  Saskatoon, Canada  •  3 months ago
      I have seen the clock at Staples Center clock stop like that before when it came to a game between the Lakers and Grizzlies, and that also had an impact in deciding the game. I think some looking in to what has happened is necessary regardless.
    • Scott  •  Columbus, Ohio  •  3 months ago
      The idea of the clock syncing makes sense as a whole over the entire game, but if that is how it works, then that is a problem. It needs to be changed to sync at clock stoppages.The bottom line is that a 10 second period at the end of a game or any other part needs to actually take 10 seconds, not be artificially adjusted to make up for time not properly accounted for earlier in the game.
      • Matt 3 months ago
        That is what is happening. If the clock didn't sync up in between whistlers, then that final 10 seconds would have only been 9 seconds before the buzzer sounded.
    • Shannon T  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  3 months ago
      Somone ask Lombardi if he would put out the same statement if the situation were reversed and the Kings lost in the same fashion.
      • MstrB 3 months ago
        Just refer to Lombardi's well documented and fined history regarding deflecting the puck into the net with a allegedly high stick.
      • michael e 3 months ago
        Alleged my butt, very clear....
      • Alissa 3 months ago
        Ah....YES he probably would. If you were a fan of the LA Kings, you would know that Dean Lombardi calls it like he sees it. And if he makes a mistake, you will here him admit to making it.
    • Svipal  •  Westbury, New York  •  3 months ago
      Why does the clock needs to sync up when there is 1-2 seconds on the clock. Terrible "timing"
      • Brenda 3 months ago
        Because otherwise the game would have ended 1 second early; difficult to sync up the display clock after the game has already ended, you know...
    • Joshua  •  Richardson, Texas  •  3 months ago
      So.... they can't switch to less sophisticated clocks? The kind that, you know, work?
    • Mike Livingston  •  New York, New York  •  3 months ago
      That picture up there is begging for some speech balloons.... I can almost hear "Khaaaaaaaannnnn!!" being shouted...
    • TheDivingCanucks  •  Los Angeles, California  •  3 months ago
      they said that the clock froze for 1 second @ 1.8 seconds left, so that would still leave .8 tenths of a second on the clock, he scored with .4 tenths.. I don't see the problem here...I say give CBJ 1 point and still they are at the bottom of the league... HAHAHA!!!!!
      • Glenn 3 months ago
        Sure Pal you are some kind of stupid. Quick math lesson. If the clock stopped at 1.8 seconds and the goal was scored at .4 seconds it took the Kings 1.4 seconds plus the 1 second of stopped clock to score the goal or 2.4 seconds total. Therefore, the puck is in the net .6 seconds(2.4 minus 1.8) after the horn.
    • MattD  •  3 months ago
      Hypothesis: the Kings clock guy stopped the clock as it went out of view for an instant after the save with about 2.5secs left assuming that the refs would blow the play dead, but as play continued he turned it back on. This is an illegal action, of course, but the NHL warroom should have caught it - or maybe they did see it and let it go anyway.

      (Dean Lombardi is fos as usual)
    • Brent Bollmeier  •  Sparta, Missouri  •  3 months ago
      True cause: Broken Flux Capacitor.
    • Libertarian  •  Clarion, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
      all electronics have some sort of "lag" but its never noticable. except in hockey where ppl know what theyre doing. Also this article, like many others on yahoo, would seriously fail a 5th grade english class
    • Thanatos  •  3 months ago
      So fine - measure it. Replay the last live 20 seconds of the game with several other clocks keeping time. See if a full 20 seconds elapsed before the clock hit zero. If all those other clocks show exactly 20 seconds have passed when the game clock hit zero then I can believe their story about how the game clock ran fast and periodically synced itself.

      If not......
    • mike k  •  Thunder Bay, Canada  •  3 months ago
      ah but who was in the grassy knoll ?
    • Billy  •  3 months ago
      In an interview, a timekeeper for the NHL said that he used a stopwatch as backup in case something when wrong with the arena clock. This was long before the scoreboards of today. Some old fashion ways work best. Think about it NHL...
    • Nick C  •  University Park, Pennsylvania  •  3 months ago
      So it was "accidental" cheating Lombardi? Accidents do happen. Good thing this happened with the Blue Jackets, whose season is over, as opposed to a team that needed the points.
    • Skeets  •  Akron, Ohio  •  3 months ago
      Ponce De Leon would be vindicated
    • Joe  •  Tucker, Georgia  •  3 months ago
      The guy on the winning team goes off on a rant about coulombs ( how strange they were playing Columbus )

      The guy on the losing side is mad as hell.

      Who would have guess that? How about asking someone removed from the situation? KTHANKS.
    • Dewman  •  3 months ago
      I've seen the delay before, just not that much and that close to the end of the period.
    • Common Sense  •  Dublin, Ohio  •  3 months ago
      TORONTO yet again drops the ball! I hope the Kings beat another team out of the playoffs by one point. Instant replay is there to make up for errors. whether it is human or mechanical.

    Yahoo! Sports Authors