Women's World Cup final:

Dr. Saturday

Columnist thinks Johnny Manziel has ruined Heisman Trophy chances for all young players

View gallery


(USA Today Sports Images)

On April Fools Day, it’s important not to take things at face value.

Yes, it’s a cynical approach, but one that usually saves embarrassment and a lengthy apology later.

So, when I read a column in the Orlando Sentinel that criticized Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Manziel for some of his offseason escapades and then asserted that the Heisman Trophy Trust should rethink giving the award to a first-year player, I had to pause.

This is a joke, right?

Columnist Matt Murschel claimed that Manziel going to NBA games and clubs with his friends, and hanging out with “scantily-clad coeds” makes him unworthy of college football’s most sacred trophy, which is just absolute nonsense.

After the offseason that Manziel has had, the Heisman Trust should rethink giving the award to a first year player again.
The pictures tell the story, there’s the ones with him at a club with friends, or courtside at an NBA game or dressed up as Scooby-Doo next to scantily-clad coeds or the ones where he is enjoying spring break on the sandy beaches of Cabo.

Each documenting the life of an average college student, yet in Manziel’s case, he is not your average college student. He’s the reigning Heisman Trophy winner, which means everything he does — good or bad — is magnified 10-fold.

View gallery


(Busted Coverage)

There’s no doubt that Manziel has been under immense scrutiny, but he hasn’t done anything that’s out of the ordinary for most college kids. More important, he hasn’t done anything illegal either by law or the NCAA. What is he supposed to do? Shut himself in his room and polish his Heisman? He’s a 20-year-old college student enjoying his college experience. Did we need to see all the pictures on Instagram and Twitter? Probably not, but saying he might not deserve a trophy for his on-field accomplishments because you don't agree with his off-field choices is short-sighted.

The Macon Telegraph wrote a story in December 2011 about Heisman Trophy winners who had less than savory backgrounds - drug arrests, murder trials and counterfeiting schemes - following their award wins. And no one called for their Heisman Trophies. Yet Manziel posing for a couple pictures is so horrible that the Heisman should rethink giving the award to another first-year player? O.J. Simpson, the 1968 Heisman winner, is laughing from his jail cell.

View gallery


(Busted Coverage)

Manziel already has admitted that he didn’t grasp the enormity of winning the award and he’s said several times that he’s learning on the fly in terms of dealing with fans and media. Murschel question’s Manziel’s maturity, but this is the same young man who voluntarily took himself off Twitter so he could temper the attention surrounding him.

He’s also been intelligent and thoughtful in his comments in the media.

Still, Murschel ends his column with this gem:

Hopefully in the future, Heisman voters will carefully consider the media savvy and maturity of a candidate along with their on the field achievements.

In honor of April Fool’s Day, I’m looking at Murschel’s column with a skeptical eye because it's hard for me to fathom someone taking this stance. It sounds like he’s a cranky columnist asking Manziel to grab his Heisman and his bottle of Dom Perignon and his pictures with the guys from Duck Dynasty and his scantily-clad coeds and get off his lawn.

- - -

Want to join the conversation? Hit us up on Twitter @YahooDrSaturday and be sure to "Like" Dr. Saturday on Facebook for football conversations and stuff you won't see on the blog.

Memorable Moments from Yahoo! Sports:

Other popular content on Yahoo! Sports:
Source: Cards closing in on deal for Carson Palmer
Yankees keep A-Rod at arm's length as season opens
Louisville guard Kevin Ware walking on crutches

View Comments (241)

Recommended for You

  • NASCAR fans defend, display Confederate flags at Daytona

    DAYTONA BEACH, Fla. (AP) — Steven Rebenstorf has numerous flags flying atop his canopy tent inside Daytona International Speedway.

    Associated Press
  • Woods goes bogey free for first time since 2013

    Tiger Woods fired his first bogey free round since 2013 on Sunday, closing with a three-under par 67 in the final round of The Greenbrier Classic. The former world number one snapped a string of 55 straight rounds with a bogey or worse -- a stretch dating back to his last bogey free round at The…

    AFP29 mins ago
  • Remember When Hope Solo Drove a Corvette Pace Car?

    Fun fact: U.S. women’s goalie Hope Solo has been stopping opponent goals for the United States since 1996 when she was a member of the U16 team. Another fun fact: she also likes to drive Corvettes on the race track. Fast. In honor of tonight’s big World Cup game vs Japan, we wanted to throwback

  • After Triple Crown, a new world greets Victor Espinoza

    This is the new reality for Victor Espinoza. A half-filled white Styrofoam cup of espresso is to his left, a black Sharpie pen is in his right hand and a 3-inch-high stack of Triple Crown commemorative posters is in front of him. For the rest of his life, Espinoza will be introduced as a Triple…

    The Associated Press38 mins ago
  • Rosberg fooled by Hamilton pit stop masterstroke

    Nico Rosberg believed he was on course to win Sunday's British Grand Prix when Mercedes team-mate Lewis Hamilton made his decision to pit for intermediate tyres in the rain-swept closing laps. "When it started raining, I felt great," said Rosberg. "I was really able to attack and pass both Williams…

  • Woman suing Marlins after mascot 'shark attack'

    Woman says the mascot's bite caused either permanent or continuing injuries in her neck and back. She's suing for $15,000 in damages.

    Big League Stew
  • How Hawk-Eye Is Destroying Tennis

    Wimbledon kicks off today. But thanks to this technology, you might tune out.

  • AP source: Derrick Williams agrees to 2 years with Knicks

    Derrick Williams is headed to New York looking for another chance to fulfill the promise he once showed. A person with direct knowledge of the deal tells The Associated Press that the former No. 2 overall draft pick has agreed to terms with the Knicks on a two-year deal worth $10 million. Williams…

    The Associated Press
  • View

    Photos of the day - July 5, 2015 (16 photos)

    Britain's Prince William, Kate the Duchess of Cambridge, their son Prince George and daughter Princess Charlotte in a pram arrive for Charlotte's Christening at St. Mary Magdalene Church in Sandringham, the pack passes a windmill in Montfoort during the second stage of the Tour de France and…

    Yahoo News
  • Trevor Bauer mimics teammates batting stances during rare plate appearance

    Trevor Bauer borrowed from Jason Kipnis, Mike Aviles and Ryan Raburn, and amazingly draws a walk.

    Big League Stew
  • Suns find another reason to dislike the Spurs

    The Phoenix Suns vaulted from long shots to finalists in the bid to land coveted free agent LaMarcus Aldridge. A person with knowledge of the situation confirmed that the Suns and Spurs were the finalists for the services of the All-Star forward. A huge banner was to have been put up outside at US…

    The Associated Press
  • Big League Stew
    Sun, Jul 5
    8:08 PM EDT
    San Francisco at Washington
    Preview Game
  • Nigeria fire Keshi and hire Amodu

    The two-year contract of Nigeria coach Stephen Keshi has been terminated because "he lacks the required commitment" and Shuaibu Amodu will replace him with immediate effect, the Nigerian football federation (NFF) has announced. "Having thoroughly reviewed the reports/findings of the NFF…

  • Play

    Team USA Takes on Japan in World Cup Finals

    The US women's team lost to Japan at the 2011 World Cup Final.

    ABC News Videos
  • U.S coach praises Japan for bringing possession into play

    By Simon Evans VANCOUVER (Reuters) - Japan's World Cup victory four years ago with a possession style approach was a turning point for the women's game that will be reflected in Sunday's final, according to United States head coach Jill Ellis. Japan became the first Asian team to win the World Cup…

  • Messi fails again with Argentina's national team

    Lionel Messi has come up short again in his attempt to succeed with Argentina's national team. Messi looked nothing like the star that he is with Barcelona on Saturday, and Argentina lost the Copa America final to Chile 4-1 on penalties, extending its 22-year title drought. Saturday's…

    The Associated Press
  • Woods drops seven behind as four tie for lead at Greenbrier

    (Reuters) - Tiger Woods fell seven strokes off the pace as four players tied for the lead after the third round of the Greenbrier Classic in West Virginia on Saturday. On a day when American Jason Bohn carded a nine-under-par 61 to join the logjam at the top, Woods battled to his highest score of…