Buzzing on Yahoo Sports:

From the Marbles

NASCAR outlines new rule requiring teams to compete at 100 percent of ability. But what the heck does that mean?

Nick Bromberg
From The Marbles

View photo


NASCAR CEO Brian France, President Mike Helton and VP of Competition Robin Pemberton. (Getty)

All 43 teams must drive hard.

That's what NASCAR told the Sprint Cup Series field today in a closed door meeting in response to the race manipulation allegations at Richmond that have sent the sanctioning body retreating and reacting in unprecedented ways.

On Monday, NASCAR penalized the teams of Michael Waltrip Racing 50 points apiece for ensuring that Martin Truex Jr., one of its three drivers, made the Chase for the Sprint Cup. With the penalty, Truex was subsequently eliminated from the Chase. On Wednesday, allegations surfaced that Joey Logano's No. 22 team had worked a deal to get around the No. 38 car and David Gilliland for position late in the race to ensure that Logano made the Chase.

Logano kept his spot in the Chase, and on Friday, NASCAR took the incredible step of adding Jeff Gordon as a 13th driver to its playoffs. As colleague Jay Busbee noted, the revisionist history in an attempt to fix what happened Saturday night was the lowest point in the sport's history. And that's not hyperbole.

And when you're in such a valley, you know that there's got to be higher ground somewhere. But you're also not sure how deep the valley is. NASCAR went wandering around on Saturday, but instead of finding a bluff, it got lost.

The closed door meeting with the Sprint Cup field Saturday lasted 17 minutes. According to NASCAR officials, it was an open dialogue. In a press conference afterwards, Brian France, Mike Helton and Robin Pemberton enforced that all teams must run to "100 percent of their ability" and outlined what is and isn't acceptable.

Asking teams to run as hard as they can to ensure that they finish in the best possible position is an idea that's fantastic in theory. But, this isn't a theory. This is 43 cars, all with varying motives at varying points racing each other at high speeds. Chaos theory is about the only theory that comes close.

There's absolutely no way to track what teams aren't running 100 percent, and then clear it with the list of caveats that NASCAR provided, like "contact with an opponent" or an alternate pit strategy. Because of the thousands of variables within a lap of a NASCAR race, it's akin to measuring intangibles. Which, as we all know, can't be defined.

But wait, here comes the kicker. By France's own admission, this new policy involves subjectivity on the part of NASCAR. And, according to Mike Helton, the enforcement of any violations of the 100 percent rule are up to NASCAR's discretion.

In essence, nothing has changed. The sanctioning body's posturing of the last week is an admitted reaction to help save the credibility of the sport, which it says was challenged at Richmond. That admission is fine, however, the continued action of NASCAR to address said credibility issues only continues to enhance them.

Before Saturday, NASCAR showed subjectivity at its own discretion, first leaving Gordon out of the Chase when penalizing MWR and then suddenly adding him in on Friday simply because France had the authority to do so. The cliche that two wrongs don't make a right may be entirely overused, but man, it's an appropriate analogy.

This latest action, in the form of a rule that will be titled 12.4-L or close to it in the rulebook, is simply ink to point to if the sanctioning body ever deems a penalty is necessary. And while that's a novel step, it's no more than that. The concept of subjectivity at NASCAR's discretion has been a cornerstone of the sport, much like France said Saturday that teams giving their all was. There's just now another rule confirming what we've known all along. It's NASCAR's show, and you better hope that discretion isn't used against you.

Follow Nick Bromberg on Twitter at @NickBromberg. Or email him at

View Comments (295)

Recommended for You

  • Adam Scott and Steve Williams end player-caddie relationship

    Adam Scott believed he could convince caddie Steve Williams to work his bag full-time in 2014-15, despite Williams' protestations that this past season would be his last in that capacity. Scott was wrong, and on Wednesday the termination of their player-caddie relationship became official.  “After…

    Devil Ball Golf
  • The Steps To Success

    Who is the one person who has had the biggest impact on your life?

  • FSU QB Jameis Winston suspended for the first half against Clemson

    Florida State has suspended starting quarterback Jameis Winston for the first half of Saturday's game against No. 22 Clemson a day after Winston shouted a sexually explicit phrase in the middle of the student union on Tuesday. Winston issued a statement prior to his regularly scheduled media meet…

    Dr. Saturday
  • Legendary announcer Jim Ross prepares for his MMA broadcast debut

    There probably aren't many sports broadcasting legends who will outright say that one of the items on their bucket list is calling a mixed martial arts event. In fact, the first time I heard it was many years back, from of all people, UFC's lead voice, Mike Goldberg.

    SB Nation
  • Adrian Peterson Has A Quietly Terrible Contract, And Cutting Him Would Save The Vikings A Ton Of Money

    The Minnesota Vikings reversed course and decided Wednesday to bar Adrian Peterson from the team   until his legal issues are resolved. The Vikings put him on the exempt/commissioner's permission list — which will keep him under contract while barring him from team activities. According to Ian…

    Business Insider
  • Why boxing stars like Floyd Mayweather want to avoid Gennady Golovkin

    Gennady Golovkin peered out of a window on the south side of a penthouse lounge in the Mandalay Bay Resort, staring at a lush golf course that the high-rolling visitors to this gambling capital eagerly fork over $300 or more a round to play. Asked if he played golf, the middleweight champion…

    Yahoo Sports
  • LeBron has new shoes, but he can't touch Jordan

    LeBron James may be one of the biggest names on the basketball court, but when it comes to sneaker sales, Michael Jordan still holds the title. Nike (NKE) unveiled 10-time All-Star Lebron James' signature shoe late Tuesday. The LeBron 12 debuted at an event at the company's headquarters in…

  • Play

    Minnesota Vikings cornerback Captain Munnerlyn on Peterson: 'I don't think it's fair at all'

    Minnesota Vikings cornerback Captain Munnerlyn comments on the team's decision to place running back Adrian Peterson on Exempt/Commissioner's Permission list.

    NFL Highlights
  • Is TUF 20 fighter Rose Namajunas the next Ronda Rousey?

    UFC superstar and bantamweight champion Ronda Rousey isn't close to being done, but she's already picked out her successor. Twenty two year-old Rose "Thug" Namajunas (2-1) is a contender on this season of The Ultimate Fighter (TUF) and, according to the "Rowdy" one, she's also "The Next Ronda…

  • Week 3 Flames: Joique, Romo highlight this week's under-started stars

    Week 3 Flames: Joique, Romo highlight this week's under-started stars Each week the Noise highlights 12-13 somewhat obscure, un-obvious names who he believes are destined to torch the competition. To qualify, each player must be started in fewer than

    Roto Arcade
  • NHL ‘Hockey Wives’ TV series will star Nicole Brown, Noureen DeWulf

    Los Angeles Kings captain Dustin Brown and Vancouver Canucks goalie Ryan Miller are established names in the NHL, whose exploits are featured on television every game night.  Nicole Brown and Noureen DeWulf are two of the cast members for “Hockey Wives,” a new reality series that chronicles the…

    Puck Daddy
  • Apply for a Master of Laws Degree Today!

    We offer LL.M. degrees for attorneys and J.S.M. degrees for business professionals. 100% online, 1 year completion, and 5 concentrations. Learn more!

    AdChoicesThomas Jefferson Law Sponsored
  • Top freshman JaQuan Lyle no longer on Oregon's roster

    After Oregon updated its men's basketball roster on Tuesday evening, it didn't take long for savvy fans to point out a key difference. JaQuan Lyle, Oregon's top freshman, is no longer on it. Lyle was not admitted to the university despite being cleared by the NCAA, reported Wednesday…

    The Dagger
  • Fredi Gonzalez Must Go

    Braves manager Fredi Gonzalez and the majority of his coaching staff must be fired if the Braves are serious about winning in the future. For the Braves' recent struggles, Frank Wren must fire manager Fredi Gonzalez and hitting coach Greg Walker. The Atlanta Braves must fire Fredi Gonzalez and Greg…

    SB Nation
    Wed, Sep 17
    4:10 PM PDT
    Washington at Atlanta
    Preview Game
  • Adrian Peterson placed on restricted list

    Adrian Peterson is officially back in limbo.  While most of the country was asleep, the news came out early Wednesday: Peterson has been placed on the exempt list, which means he'll stay away from the Vikings (for both team activities and games) while Peterson's child abuse charges are addressed. …

    Roto Arcade
  • Play

    Knile Davis needs to fly off of the waiver wire

    Rotoworld: Adam Levitan joins Jenna Corrado to discuss the key pickups that need to be made off of the waiver wire heading into Week 3. On the top of Levitan's list is Chiefs' RB Knile Davis, who would get the start if Jamaal Charles can't go.

    NBC Sports
  • Recap: 'Big Brother' Final 4 Snark With Andy Herren

    One ridiculous game twist ruined Frankie Grande's otherwise admirable game. Man. We're down to four: Victoria (who is about as threatening as a panda in a pop-up book), Cody (a man with gold pecs who's turning in a bronze-worthy performance), Derrick (a genius who is nice enough to feed his fellow…

  • Week 3 Ranks: Defense/Special Teams

    Week 3 Ranks: Defense/Special Teams More Week 3 Rankings: QB | RB | WR | TE | K | DST The following list comprises the top 20 team defense/special team rankings for Week 1 of each Yahoo! Sports fantasy expert. The list is ordered by the overall top 20

    Yahoo Sports
  • Dwight Howard has license suspended for running red lights, being dumb

    Rockets center Dwight Howard may play in Houston now, but he is still paying for his years in Orlando, getting his license suspended for failing to pay his red light tickets in Orlando. In a more lighthearted twist, Rockets center has gotten his license suspended for his failure to pay a red light…

    SB Nation