YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

    Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

    To get started, first
    Big League Stew

    A.J. Burnett’s fractured face would still be OK if National League used a DH

    A.J. Burnett has 37 career sacrifice bunts. (AP)Before he rehabilitates his career with the Pittsburgh Pirates, A.J. Burnett must rehabilitate his body after undergoing surgery to fix a fractured right orbital bone.

    Burnett, who fouled a pitch off his face during batting practice Wednesday — ESPN has video — will have surgery Friday in Pittsburgh. At least it's not a pitching injury. Right?

    This seems like a good time to bring up how pitchers batting is a bad idea and both leagues should use the designated hitter.

    The American League adopted the DH in 1973, freeing its pitchers to fully concentrate on, well, pitching (aside from World Series appearances, that is). The NL has been stubborn about it, obviously, and we don't seem to be on the verge of change there. As a result, their pitchers spend valuable time practicing their hitting when they could be doing more pitcher-ly pursuits. The same goes for AL pitchers come interleague play.

    No matter that it was a freak occurrence, if Burnett wasn't wasting time at the plate trying to bunt (bunting — there's another abomination!), he would be preparing for his first Grapefruit League appearance and not for surgery.

    This obviously is not how Burnett or the Pirates wanted him to start his time in Pittsburgh, which acquired him with cash from the New York Yankees for prospects in late February. Projected as the ace of the staff, perhaps, Burnett is trying to recover from back-to-back seasons of having an ERA over 5.00. He's got two more years to go on an $82 million contract he signed with New York before the 2009 season — money he won't be earning for a while because of ... bunting practice.

    Burnett has 37 career sacrifice bunts and 35 career hits (most of which came with the Marlins in the NL from 1999-2005), so he has an idea of what to do in the batter's box. But he still doesn't belong there. Batters do. Sometimes, occasionally, once in a blue moon, it's fun to watch a pitcher hit. And fewer times still, he actually produces something. Most of the time, they're up there flailing away. The beer vendor would appear to have about the same chance to get on base.

    Before Bud Selig leaves the commissioner's office — if it ever happens — he ought to make it his mission to fully unite the leagues and make them play under the same rules. DHs for all! That way, the A.J. Burnetts of the future won't put their careers at risk messing around where they don't belong.

    Big BLS h/t: Rob Biertempfel of the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review

    Spring Training has arrived! Follow Dave on Twitter — @AnswerDave and engage The Stew on Facebook for your fill of Grapefruit and Cactus!

     
    • Art M  •  2 months ago
      It's actually AJ Burnett's fault. If he had pitched better with the Yankees, he wouldn't find himself in the NL re-learning how to bunt.
      • Jose 2 months ago
        Hahaha!
    • Michael G  •  Columbus, Ohio  •  2 months ago
      What a dumb article. Foul tips happen and hit batters all the time. Think they need to get some writers who actually know something about baseball!
      • Jose 2 months ago
        Bingo. Effective bunters can control where the ball will travel--especially in batting practice. Ask Greg Maddux, not David Brown.
    • catspaw27  •  Salem, Oregon  •  2 months ago
      Burnett is a better batter then David Brown is a writer.
      • Dudenessness 2 months ago
        better bunter even...
      • catspaw27 2 months ago
        Dudeness yes, a better bunter as well.

        When did Yahoo turn in to a barroom discussion? I would prefer to read news, not the opinion of a 2-bit blogger who doesn't understand THE GAME.
      • Mean Green 2 months ago
        Come on now, kids... These Yahoo bloggers produce TONS of material, some of it informative, some of it insightful (don't laugh, and no not inciteful), and some of it just plain interesting. If you just want the facts, the Standings link and the Stats link are readily available at the top of the page.
    • Krazy K  •  St Charles, Missouri  •  2 months ago
      Your hero Bud Selig has already single handedly run the game into the ground. "That way, the A.J. Burnetts of the future won't put their careers at risk messing around where they don't belong." So the AJ Burnett's should be playing patty cake instead?
    • SantoAperfect10  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  2 months ago
      His face would be OK if he knew how to bunt.... Must be nice to earn money posting junk stories like this....
    • Giland  •  Phoenix, Arizona  •  2 months ago
      Sorry, I though the pitchers where baseball players, and baseball players swing the bat. If all you want is something to throw the ball, buy a throwing machine, they cost way less than a star pitcher, and have better consistency too.
    • L R  •  Richardson, Texas  •  2 months ago
      It is a bad idea in the NL and the AL. It allows pitchers to be head hunters without fear of payback. It rewards one dimensional players. Expand the rosters from 25 to 26. Allow a team to use a DH for the pitcher's spot but, if they use it, either the DH or the pitcher is out of the game. If the pitcher hits for himself, no change.
      • gbaby 2 months ago
        "It allows pitchers to be head hunters without fear of payback."

        Not true at all. Normally if a pitcher seems to be intentionally hitting batters on the other team the other team retaliates by going after the other position players, not the pitcher. Yeah he might get thrown at occasionally but it doesn't really matter who gets pegged as long as someone does.
      • Jose 2 months ago
        That's technically a PH, though, right? I mean, I think the DH rule is horrible. I'd rather apply NL's rules because it's more of a combined team effort. Let's face it, a DH would rather not be substituted for a pinch runner or other hitter and a pitcher who doesn't bat has more pitching stamina, which eliminates the humanistic element of being a pitcher--battling the circumstances of playing both offense and defense. A PH is more dynamic because you can use different players throughout the game in different circumstances. A PR can come in for a PH. Ask Travis Hafner if he likes someone else subbing for him at DH in the middle of a game.
    • FD  •  Lewisburg, Ohio  •  2 months ago
      Injuries happen in sports how about lets put a cage around the pitcher while they pitch as well so they don't get hit by a line drive. This article is insane
      • Steve C 2 months ago
        No, merely inane.
    • T  •  Peoria, Illinois  •  2 months ago
      DH was introduced to the AL not to have the pitchers focus on their pitching it was to increase the AL offense to catch up to the NL.
    • Bruce  •  Cincinnati, Ohio  •  2 months ago
      Why don't we just have an offence and defence like they do in football. The DH rule is awful and should be done away with in the AL. This story is a joke!!
    • T  •  2 months ago
      Get rid of the DH!
    • Dan  •  2 months ago
      Why is it when a freak accident occurs to a well known player do we need to change all the rules, but when an unknown actually gets killed because of substandard equipment (like, say, a broken bat hitting him because the material it's made of splinters and flies towards people in the infield) it's just an accident?
    • Gus  •  2 months ago
      no no no....nice over-reaction. sucks for Burnett, but come on. next time a pitcher gets drilled in the head, lets make a move to have batters face pitching machines in the games.
    • Bostfanssuck  •  Wallingford, Connecticut  •  2 months ago
      Someone gets hurt change the rules!!! It's sports injuries happen. Maybe if Burnett had been hitting all along in the AL, he would have known how to bunt!
    • Joe  •  Dayton, Ohio  •  2 months ago
      I'm totally against usage of the DH. It's not about watching the pitcher bat, or tradition. It's about seeing a total team effort. Ever compare a typical NL box score to an AL box? Baseball is a thinking man's game. What fan doesn't love thinking about, "who to pinch-hit? when to pinch-hit? should I take the pitcher out? what's that do to the batting order?". Injuries happen. I remember John Tudor busting his knee while sitting on the bench.
    • Deeprough  •  Sacramento, California  •  2 months ago
      DH is wrong. Baseball was designed for nine players to play defense and the same nine players to play offense. Chicks dig the long ball, remeber the Atlanta Braves Maddox, Schmoltz and Glavine. Pitchers that can hit are more fun to watch than DH hitters. DH is just a way for players that can't p;ay defense anymore. Managing pitchers, pinch hitters, player changes is more fun to watch than 10 pitchers running out there and there is no strategy. Dump the the overpaid professional hitters and let pitchers be athletes.
    • S  •  Phoenix, Arizona  •  2 months ago
      AJ BURNETT GIVES ME BAD GAS!
    • kevin  •  Los Angeles, California  •  2 months ago
      Leave the GAME alone. EVERY player should know how to bunt because it's something they've done since little league and most likely all the way up through their college careers. I coached high school baseball for 10 years and I know if I ever bump into ANY of them now they would be able to show me proper technique. I assure you that it was all A.J.'s fault. Horrible bat angle and I bet the ball was not in the strike zone. I dont even have to see video....he poked his bat at the ball and boom!!
    • jay expert  •  Boston, Massachusetts  •  2 months ago
      i could not dissagree with you more!! the DH is abomination!! the AL should get rid of it! if you watch baseball at all you have to agree that NL baseball is a lot more entertaining than AL no stratagy baseball.
    • Broad_St_Bully_16  •  Boca Raton, Florida  •  2 months ago
      There's no place in baseball for the dumbest rule ever. Get rid of the DH.
      You take the field, you bat..end of story.
      If you're too old to play the field, retire.
      There should be no going to the American League just to get more at bats.
      DH. Get rid of it now and play REAL baseball again.

    Yahoo! Sports Authors