A strange trend develops among elite prep basketball recruits

Ben Rohrbach

Newark Star-Ledger reporter Matthew Stanmyre tackled an odd trend that has permeated prep basketball and hasn't been properly discussed until now: The matter of budding young hoops stars repeating a grade in middle school in order to gain an edge.

In fact, as Stanmyre notes, New Jersey's top four recruits and four of the Star-Ledger's five returning All-State underclassmen stayed back in either seventh or eighth grade.

Proponents of the strategy cited late birthdays, maturity issues and even academic reasons for repeating a grade, but the real answer is probably much simpler than that.

“It’s not because a kid is not doing well in school or is too young for his grade,” legendary Jersey City (N.J.) St. Anthony High coach Bob Hurley told Stanmyre. “It’s just because you’ll be one year older in high school and you’ll be that much better of a player.”

Metuchen (N.J.) St. Joseph's High senior center Karl Towns, Newark (N.J.) St. Benedict's High junior point guard Isaiah Briscoe, Roselle (N.J.) Catholic High junior shooting guard Malachi Richardson and Linden (N.J.) High senior center Quadri Moore all repeated a year in middle school, according to the Star-Ledger report.

Like many states, New Jersey limits an individual's competition to four years of high school, so repeating a grade prior to becoming a frehman takes advantage of a loophole so long as the student-athlete is 18 on Sept. 1 of his senior year of high school.

Briscoe pled with his father to repeat eighth grade, the report said, "so I could dominate and work on my body more and just elevate my game before I get to high school.”

Who's to argue? Briscoe is now the No. 15 ranked player in the Class of 2015. “It was just a good thing, and it worked out for everybody,” his father, George Briscoe, added. “Now it’s safe to say he’s in line for a scholarship. Wouldn’t you say so? There was no loss.”

This is an accepted practice among elite recruits across the nation. The list includes projected 2014 NBA draft No. 1 pick Andrew Wiggins as well as Nerlens Noel, who was expected to be the top overall pick this past June until falling to No. 6 on the board.

It doesn't always play out perfectly. Once the No. 1 overall recruit in the Class of 2012, Shabazz Muhammad appeared destined to be a top NBA draft choice, but an L.A. Times piece revealing his true age of 20 -- as opposed to the 19 he reportedly had presented for years -- may have contributed to him dropping into the middle of the first round.

Oddly, once many prep basketball stars -- including Noel, Wiggins and Towns -- grow into their bodies while dominating younger competition, eventually establishing themselves as elite recruits, they reclassify back to their original grade.

“Me and my family talked about it, and it just felt like it was the best decision for me basketball-wise, to go and move to the next grade,” Towns told The Star-Ledger. “Especially with this year’s recruiting class, I think almost all top 10 players did it and they all reclassified up. It’s one of those things that just seems to be happening now.”

Towns, a University of Kentucky commit and now a top-10 player in this year's senior class, owns a 4.07 GPA. After repeating seventh grade upon transferring schools and then reclassifying this summer, he will graduate the same year he was originally expected to -- pending the completion of a half-dozen online courses this summer.

As a result, it's hard to argue against the strategy, particularly considering he earned himself a full ride to play for John Calipari's Wildcats. It's just strange, that's all.

Want more on the best stories in high school sports? Visit RivalsHigh or connect with Prep Rally on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

  • Steelers want NFL to investigate Ndamukong Suh kicking Ben Roethlisberger

    Miami Dolphins defensive tackle Ndamukong Suh won’t get the benefit of the doubt from many people when it comes to a dirty play. The Pittsburgh Steelers were not happy over a play last week in which Suh appeared to kick their quarterback, Ben Roethlisberger. The play happened in the fourth quarter, long after Roethlisberger tore the meniscus in his left knee (that injury will keep him out an estimated four-to-six weeks).

    Shutdown Corner
  • Favorable Notice of Allegations will benefit both Rick Pitino, Louisville

    Louisville coach Rick Pitino could face a suspension. The most noteworthy aspect of the Notice of Allegations released Thursday by Louisville is what it doesn’t contain. There was not one word from the man who could have done the most damage to Rick Pitino and the Cardinals basketball program.

    The Dagger
  • Yakupov returns to Edmonton, playing noteworthy role with Blues

    Nail Yakupov returns to Edmonton tonight, for the first time since the Oct. 7 trade that sent him to St. Louis. To nobody’s surprise, Yakupov wants to make a statement to the team that dealt him away. “I’d like to get two points here in this building for sure,” Yakupov told reporters, per Global News. “Can’t wait.” The first overall pick in 2012, Yakupov struggled through four erratic campaigns in Edmonton before getting a much-needed change of scenery. Though things started well — as a rookie, he scored 17 goals and 31 points during the 48-game lockout campaign — but eventually got to the point where the speedy Russian was playing a complimentary role, at best, in Edmonton’s forward group. There

  • Klein to be paired with Staal against the Red Wings on Wednesday

    Alain Vigneault confirmed today that Kevin Klein will return to the Rangers lineup tonight and will be paired with Marc Staal. (NYR) Klein and Staal have played 929 minutes together since they have been teammates and when they are on the ice at 5-on-5 the Rangers have scored 53% of the goals but only had 45.3% of the shot attempts. (Stats.HockeyAnalysis.com) Ryan McDonagh will remain paired with Nick Holden on the right side and Brady Skjei will skate with Adam Clendening. Dylan McIlrath will be a healthy scratch an Henrik Lundqvist will be in goal.

  • The soon-to-be U.S. women's national team star you really should know

    Lynn Williams didn’t take long to make an impact in her USWNT debut. Because Lynn Williams took just 50 seconds to score her first national team goal. In a highly experimental game for head coach Jill Ellis, who fielded a three-woman back line and gave five players their debuts, the U.S. dominated but didn’t convert all of its possession and shots until Williams stepped into the fray.

    FC Yahoo
  • Who will win - Arkansas or Auburn?

    Yahoo Sports looks at the key matchups for Saturday's SEC battle in Auburn.

    Yahoo Sports Videos
  • Should the Mets acquire Maybin?

    In a post brainstorming trade ideas for this winter, Tigers fan and FanSided contributor Ben Rosener suggests Detroit send OF Cameron Maybin and utility-man Andrew Romine to the Mets for Juan Lagares and two prospects. Maybin, 29, hit .315 with a .383 OBP, four home runs, 14 doubles, 43 RBI and 15 stolen bases in 94 games for the Tigers in 2016. He is a career .259 hitter during roughly 3,000 plate appearances. Maybin will earn $9 million in 2017, after which he is eligible to be a free agent. Romine, 30, hit .236 with just two HR, eight stolen bases and 16 RBI, while playing every position in 2016, including pitching one inning in relief. Tigers GM Al Avila recently told local reporters that

  • Hellmann’s sponsoring Sprint Cup race at Talladega

    Just a few days before Talladega Superspeedway hosts its second NASCAR weekend of the season, the track has announced a title sponsor for Sunday’s Sprint Cup race. Originally called the Alabama 500, the 188-lap race is now labelled the Hellmann’s 500. Hellmann’s, a long-time sponsor of Dale Earnhardt Jr. and JR Motorsports, produces Hellmann’s Real Mayonnaise. The Hellmann’s 500 is the second elimination race of the Chase for the Sprint Cup and whittle the Chase field from 12 to eight drivers. The race can be seen at 2 p.m. ET on NBCSN.

    NASCAR Talk
  • Here are your United States Grand Prix times on NBC, NBCSN

    This week, Formula 1 heads to the United States for the fifth United States Grand Prix to be held at Circuit of The Americas in Austin. It seems hard to believe this is the fifth running here already, but it is. The championship battle rages between Nico Rosberg and Lewis Hamilton, with the Mercedes AMG Petronas duo separated by 33 points, with Rosberg ahead. Here are the full times and details for this weekend’s coverage, with race coverage starting Sunday, at 2:30 p.m. ET on NBC. Lights out is at 3 p.m. ET/2 p.m. CT and local time, from Austin. We should also note Off the Grid: Austria premieres at 12:30 p.m. ET on NBCSN, following coverage of Practice 1 on Friday. Mercedes teammates Lewis

  • No. 1 vs. No. 2: First NHL game between top two draft picks

    Auston Matthews and Patrik Laine became the ninth pair of No. 1 and No. 2 overall draft picks to face off in subsequent NHL season since 2000. Patrik Laine took the first round, completing the Winnipeg Jets' comeback from a four-hole deficit -- and capping

    Yahoo Sports
  • What Vin Scully did instead of attending NLCS Game 4 at Dodger Stadium

    Instead, in broadcast booth No. 1 in the Vin Scully press box, his seat is filled by Fox’s play-by-play duo of Joe Buck and John Smoltz. Now, this isn’t a surprise, Vin retired and said there would be no postseason assignment because you can only really say goodbye once. Vin isn’t anywhere in Dodger Stadium — unless you count the various pictures and tributes.

    Big League Stew
  • Brian Campbell expected to be healthy scratch

    Blackhawks defenseman Brian Campbell is expected to be a healthy scratch Friday in Columbus, according to the Chicago Sun-Times. It’s a somewhat surprising development considering the attention Campbell’s return to Chicago was given over the summer, but the ‘Hawks have eight defensemen on the roster and that means, when everyone’s healthy, two have to sit each game. “We don’t want the same two guys sitting out all the time,” head coach Joel Quenneville said. “Sometimes you don’t want to tinker with a winning lineup, and sometimes . . . you’ve got to get them in there to play. That’s what we’re visiting.” The Sun-Times says to expect Trevor van Riemsdyk to get back into the lineup against the

  • Jimmy Howard makes statement, but knows his place with Red Wings

    The New York Rangers skated in on Jimmy Howard in waves. The scoreboard at the end of the Detroit Red Wings’ 2-1 victory at Madison Square Garden read ’32 saves,’ but that was a shallow evaluation of Howard’s night: The breakaways, odd-man rushes and high-percentage scoring chances he stopped en route to that victory. It was Howard’s first appearance since April 15, when he gave up four goals on 30 shots in Game 2 of the Wings’ first-round loss against the Tampa Bay Lightning.

    Puck Daddy
  • Why Arsenal will finally take a step forward in the Champions League (no, seriously)

    Mesut Ozil celebrates the second of his three goals against Ludogorets. For Arsene Wenger and Arsenal, something feels a bit different this season. A 6-0 destruction of Ludogorets in the Champions League on Wednesday has Arsenal level on points with Paris Saint-Germain at the top of Group A, but the remaining head-to-head fixture against the French champions will take place at the Emirates Stadium in London.

    FC Yahoo
  • Fox Sports' Nick Wright: Giants QB Eli Manning is a bad teammate

    On Monday, a day removed from a 27-23 victory over the Baltimore Ravens, New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning appeared on WFAN radio with Mike Francesa. After being bombarded with questions about wide receiver Odell Beckham Jr., Manning finally said “you could get sick” of OBJ’s antics if he’s not performing well. The comments caused immediate backlash for Manning. And after months of people criticizing him for defending Beckham Jr., those very same people began criticizing him for not defending Beckham Jr. firmly enough. Manning clarified his WFAN comments on Tuesday, saying his words had been twisted around by the media and that he was specifically referring to reporters when making those

    Giants Wire
  • There are two Antonio Browns, and one of them saved the other from football oblivion

    This is Antonio Brown. Now, a little over a decade after he left this Miami neighborhood for an uncertain future, his No. 84 Steelers jersey is everywhere – as popular as any Dolphins jersey on this particular South Florida game day. There are people wearing 84 who went on a Steelers Eastern Caribbean cruise with him last offseason, keeping photos of volleyball games and even the ID tag needed to board the boat.

    Yahoo Sports
  • Russell Westbrook sub-Instagrammed Kevin Durant with cupcake photo

    Kevin Durant announced his departure from the Thunder to the Warriors on July 4. Russell Westbrook first publicly responded, using the loosest definition of response, several weeks later. Or so we thought. Westbrook apparently sent Durant a subtle message July 4, using a symbol popularized on the Thunder by former teammate Kendrick Perkins (who had very interesting thoughts on the Durant-Westbrook dynamic). Lee Jenkins of Sports Illustrated: Westbrook and Durant were not best buds, but they were peerless partners, a souped-up Stockton and Malone, transporting a mini market to the big time. Westbrook’s closest friends are actually former high school teammates, long-standing wing men like Donnell

  • NASCAR weekend schedule for Talladega Superspeedway

    The Sprint Cup and Camping World Truck Series are in action this weekend at Talladega Superspeedway as both series hold Chase elimination races at the 2.66-mile track. The Sprint Cup Series competes in the Hellmann’s 500, and the Truck Series, in its first race in two weeks, competes in the Fred’s 250. Here’s the full weekend schedule for NASCAR including TV and radio times. All times are Eastern. Friday, Oct. 21 8:30 a.m. – 8 p.m. – Sprint Cup garage open 11 a.m. – 9 p.m. – Truck Series garage open 1 – 1:55 p.m. – Truck series practice (Fox Sports 1) 2 – 2:55 p.m. – Sprint Cup practice (NBCSN, Motor Racing Network) 3 – 3:55 p.m. – Final Truck Series practice (FS1) 4:30 – 5:25 p.m. – Final Sprint

    NASCAR Talk
  • Lower stakes, but Sharks aim to ‘make a statement’ in return to Pittsburgh

    PITTSBURGH (AP) The stakes are nowhere near the same: hockey immortality versus two points in the standings in the second week of a long season. Still, the San Jose Sharks and Pittsburgh Penguins expect the atmosphere to be a little more heated than the usual NHL October product when they meet Thursday night barely four months removed from Pittsburgh’s six-game victory in the Stanley Cup Final. “It was obviously tough to go on that long a journey and lose the way we did,” San Jose coach Peter DeBoer said. “I don’t think there was any doubt at the end of the day they deserved to win, but at the same time I think for us it’s a chance to go in, and we’re a different team this year, and make a statement

  • ALCS Game 5: Ryan Merritt pitches Indians to World Series

    Cleveland Indians starter Ryan Merritt proved as much during Wednesday’s Game 5 start against the Toronto Blue Jays in the American League Championship Series. In just his second major-league start, Merritt turned in a fantastic performance during Cleveland’s 3-0 win, sending the Indians to their first World Series since 1997. Merritt was masterful against a tough Toronto lineup, holding them to just two hits over 4 2/3 scoreless innings.

    Big League Stew
  • Hossa's journey to 500 goals; Ottawa's attendance issues (Puck Headlines)

    Here are your Puck Headlines: A glorious collection of news and views collected from the greatest blogosphere in sports and the few, the proud, the mainstream hockey media. • Mini Pekka Rinne watches the Nashville Predators take on the Dallas Stars. • Why has home attendance become an issue for the Ottawa Senators?

    Puck Daddy
  • UEFA Europa League preview: RVP ready for “special” Old Trafford return

    We’ve got a Champions League-level match down in the UEFA Europa League on Thursday, highlighted by an Old Trafford visit by a Turkish giant. Old pal Robin Van Persie and Fenerbahce visit Manchester United on Thursday, and the home side would do well with all three points. Fener has a road draw at Zorya and a home win versus Feyenoord, while United beat Zorya after losing in the Netherlands. “In the last match I had a game against one of my first teams, Feyenoord, and next it’s United,” Van Persie said on ManUtd.com. “I am looking forward to it. I am now playing for Fenerbahce and I want to do well for my team but of course it will be special to play ‘at home’ [Old Trafford] in a great stadium

  • Messi hat trick powers Barcelona to Champions League rout of Guardiola's Man City

    Lionel Messi celebrates his third in Barcelona’s 4-0 thrashing of Man City. Pep Guardiola may be in the process of building a fine Barcelona replica with Manchester City, but when faced with the real deal on Wednesday, it was painfully clear that there isn’t yet a substitute for Barca’s ball-wizardry machine. The little magician scored a hat trick in the 4-0 Barca win, with Neymar getting the final goal, as the game ended with both sides reduced to 10 men.

    FC Yahoo
  • Rangers get Kevin Klein back vs. Red Wings

    The New York Rangers defense is getting a little healthier. While Dan Girardi is still banged up, it looks like Kevin Klein is good to go against the Detroit Red Wings in tonight’s Wednesday Rivalry Night matchup. Perhaps Alain Vigneault might have a curveball up his sleeve, but at the moment, Dylan McIlrath seems like the probable loser in a game of defenseman musical chairs with Klein returning. Klein does a little bit of everything for the Rangers, including putting together strangely identical scoring seasons of nine goals and 17 assists in both 2014-15 and 2015-16. It’s also important to note that he sometimes sports the sort of facial hair that’s reminiscent of a villain in a silent film.

  • Hot Seat Index: Trent Baalke has made a mess of the 49ers

    Colleague Frank Schwab did a thorough job breaking down why the San Francisco 49ers are the worst team in the NFL right now, and could remain at or near the bottom of the league for a while. From subpar drafts to an avoidance (refusal?) to sign big-money free agents to his force-out of coach Jim Harbaugh after the 2014 season, general manager Trent Baalke has made a mess of the Niners. As Schwab notes, Baalke and the team did have to deal with an almost unprecedented offseason in 2015, as a litany of key players decided to retire.

    Shutdown Corner