YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

    Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

    To get started, first
    Devil Ball Golf

    Teeing Off: Should the PGA Tour force winners to play Kapalua?

     

    Welcome to the new season of Teeing Off, where Devil Ball editor Jay Busbee and head writer Shane Bacon take a day's topic and smack it all over the course. Suggest a future topic by writing jay.busbee@yahoo.com, or hit us on Twitter at @jaybusbee and @shanebacon. Today, we kick off the year by wondering why the heck last year's champions aren't showing up at the champions-only kickoff event.

    Busbee: It's here! It's finally here! The start of the 2012 season! And it begins with ... well, no offense to Kapalua, but with a bit of a fizzle. Only two players in the top 10 are even at the Hyundai Tournament of "Champions," and that just isn't good enough. We need more. We need better. We need more of the better. But how, exactly, do we do this, Shane?

    Bacon: It seems the only way to get guys to come anywhere is money. Lots and lots of money. But golf is becoming big enough where it seems demanding a little is OK for the PGA Tour to do, right? I think making former winners play in this event seems legit. I mean, forcing a millionaire to go to a golf course with no cut in Hawaii seems pretty horrible, doesn't it? Could the PGA Tour do that? Does demanding PGA Tour winners to show up at ONE tournament go against everything that golf stands for?

    Busbee: It's such a tremendous pain to have to deal with the "independent contractor" nonsense for non-major tournaments. The opening of the PGA season should have all the pomp and circumstance of baseball's Opening Day, the NFL's kickoff weekend and NASCAR's Daytona 500. Instead, it's more like the NBA, where nobody pays attention until Christmas ... or the Masters, whichever. I don't think it's out of line to demand tour winners go to ONE tournament. Question is, how do they go about that? Make it part of the deal in getting the card?

    Bacon: I think they make it part in getting the exemptions that come with a win. Win a regular PGA Tour event and you get two years exempt on tour. That is only an option if you come to the Tournament of Champions to start the year. I mean, it might seem demanding at the time, but in 10 years nobody would think different about it. Plus, it would give the PGA Tour a great start to the season during a time when all other sports are really hitting their stride.

    Busbee: Agreed. See the PGA Tour commercial during the Orange Bowl? (Much more interesting than the game itself, but I digress.) Golf needs a foothold early, and putting the game's best on display early would do just that. I like the exemption idea; you want the benefits, you pay the price. You think golf has the stones to do that? I could see them phasing it in -- say, less than five years of service, you have to obey us, at least initially.

    Bacon: They'd never do it, but it sure would make it more fun. It's like the Grand Slam of Golf. How horrible is it to be forced to play in an event AFTER YOU WIN A MAJOR?! I'd like them to do this, just because it would give us all a chance to see all the winners from the previous year once before they go back into hibernation before Torrey Pines. And then the Masters. Golf has become such a top-heavy sport that if they don't figure something out fast, the big names will play in 10-15 events a year on either tour and call it a season.

    Busbee: Here's one other element: sponsors. You think Random Midwestern Insurance Co. is going to want to sponsor a tournament when the best players in the game are taking a month off? Not a chance. Golf needs to figure a way to leverage sponsors in the equation and put more pressure on the players to, you know, play.

    We can always hope, right?

    Bacon: And if nothing else, we get golf on at night this weekend. And Bubba.

    All right, you're up. Should the tour force its champions to play in the season-starting event? Have your say!

    Other popular Y! Sports content:
    Video: Jon Gruden's goofy gaffe during the Orange Bowl
    Trade gives Carlos Zambrano another shot at happiness
    Lavish athlete retreats: Where do stars get away from it all?

    Watch Full Count!
     

    27 comments

    • R  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  4 months ago
      How about a guaranteed field of 30? If you have 30 winners and 22 show up, invitations go out to the next highest on the previous year's money list (in order) until the field reaches 30. If Rory, Eldick & others want to snub the PGA tour, let them. Give other players a head start on money to make it tougher for the snubbers to win the FedEx Cup or get into the Tour Championship. This way you might get a guy like Jason Day into the field. You could also assign more FedEx Cup points to the event.
      • reporterjoe 4 months ago
        The field is made up of the best on the PGA tour, regardless of what the non-afficionados think. They are all winners from the prior year.

        That said, when a field gets shaved to 27 as did this one, your suggestion is an excellent one. It would be tough to get last minute players into this venue, but I think it would be worth a shot. I am sure they do not consider this as they do not want to tarnish the fundamental qualification of having won an official tour event the prior year. Since it would be to round out the field, I don't think it would lessen the view of the field at all.
    • Richard C  •  Tacoma, Washington  •  4 months ago
      yes they should do something to get the top ten to play for the game of golf
    • nono  •  Oklahoma City, Oklahoma  •  4 months ago
      The best golfers that the USA has to offer are playing this tournament. I think the writer meant to say that the "big" name USA personalities aren't there. The Europeans and Aussies need a time of rest since they have played solidly throughout 2011. There isn't anything wrong with this tournament.
    • landl47  •  4 months ago
      One of the problems (not the only one) is that so many of the best golfers are Europeans or play on the European tour. Hardly any of them are playing in this event. Isn't it time that the PGA and the European tour got together and co-ordinated their schedule so that the top golfers could appear at the tournaments that both the PGA and the European tour agree are category 1 events? They have an arrangement like this in tennis, so that the best events, not just the majors, have the best fields. The PGA can no longer claim to be the only game in town, so it needs to become creative to ensure more events like this don't become second-class.
    • Sue Nami  •  4 months ago
      Uniquely interesting field. That the big names are absent does nothing to dilute from it if you're not a celebrity-watcher. It'll be interesting to see how many among such an unusual cast of winners in 2011 fare in the new season.
    • Lance  •  4 months ago
      I think the simplest idea is to offer the top 10 of this tourney each year a 2 year exemption to this event. A guy could win 3 times one year and not win the next, still be a top player and not be qualified to come to Maui. The exemption wouldn't guarantee a bigger field but it would guarantee and bigger list of invitees. There's always going to be those that can't come for whatever reason, but with adding a potential 20 more invitees each year it would be more interesting and still be a solid field.
    • Fourmorebeers  •  4 months ago
      It is just too early in the year. In a global game the Australians and South Africans have to have some time to play their golf in the summer.

      The golfing year begins in April.
    • TL  •  4 months ago
      From a legal standpoint I think the only way the tour could get away with forcing the players is if they were employees of the Tour which they are not.
      • reporterjoe 4 months ago
        TL,

        Your post is exactly correct.

        These guys do not work for the PGA Tour, they are independent contractors. As soon as they are forced to report to a work place at a given time, (in this case for a tournament), they are no longer considered independent contractors. The PGA would be forced to then claim them as an employee, and pay all the required employee benefits. They already broach that fine line by requiring so many appearances to remain a tour member. That is about as close to becoming an employer by federal standards as they want to go.

        The writers never mention this in their article. But then, these reporters are clueless as to facts.
    • geo  •  Grand Rapids, Michigan  •  4 months ago
      Judging from the number of responses, this would seem to be much ado about nothing.
      • larry n 4 months ago
        Most of the Busby articles are this way.
    • joja  •  Albany, New York  •  4 months ago
      Joe - I sorta agree with you, I love the game as well and I don't need the top 10 to be interested BUT without question having all of the winners there would certainly help kick start the year.
    • greydragon53  •  4 months ago
      Move it closer to the mainland, Puerto Rico or somewhere in Mexico maybe, that would get more players to show up and yes this is one tournament where appearance money would definitely guarantee a better turnout.
      • R 4 months ago
        Don't think it would because of the Sony Open the following week. Nobody will do the Puerto Rico to Hawaii turnaround.
      • greydragon53 4 months ago
        Not much different than flying from Florida to Hawaii after skipping the one in Maui.
      • A Yahoo! User 4 months ago
        leave it where it is
    • Ron  •  Oklahoma City, Oklahoma  •  4 months ago
      I don't agree with forcing them to go to a tournament. Why not make it the last event of the year and start the year with a full field. It's free money and they could take out a lot of this "fluff" at the end. Just because you won last year, why should you get a head start on the field for the next year. That is like giving last years Superbowl champ a 1 game lead at the start of the season or the Daytona 500 winner from last year getting a half lap lead.
    • billieboy  •  4 months ago
      Jay Busbee ,
      for crying out aloud , stop COMPLAINING !
      Just enjoy what this tournament have and see who wins , that ' s all man !

      As for this tournament , why not make it part of the FED - EX Playoff Series, and see
      how many will show up at the end of the year ! ! ! !
      ENUFF SAID ! ! ! !
    • Joe  •  4 months ago
      Lets be real here. Offering MORE money to entice a "big name" field to play golf in Hawaii is just ridiculous. Think about it....GOLF in HAWAII in January!!! If players don' want to play then so bet it. I will not be sad if Kapalua doesn't have a great field this year. I will watch because I love golf. Period.
    • Czech  •  4 months ago
      I don’t even know what is more despicable—having the complete lack of character, ethics, and integrity of a Tiger Woods, or blindly worshiping someone like Tiger Woods?
    • Bill K  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  4 months ago
      Amen! Can we cut the silliness how people like Lefty & Tiger love the history/traditions of golf?!? Those two ENDLESSLY blow off several cool historic tournaments!
      And if Tiger wants to repair his image, why can't he ever play in a beloved event like ST JUDE'S in Memphis?!? i guess I'm thinking too much.
    • BE Real  •  Boca Raton, Florida  •  4 months ago
      WHEN IT WAS THE MERCEDES CHAMPIONSHIP, MORE TOP GOLFERS SHOWED UP. WHAT MILLOINIAR WANTS TO BE SEEN IN A HUYUNDIA???
    • Yosemite  •  Monterey, California  •  4 months ago
      Just cancel the tournament if there is not any interest in it. It would be at least intertersting for TV if it were a Pro Am. As it stands now who would even turn on the TV to watch it?
    • alfonso  •  4 months ago
      How about $5 million splashed in pot instead of so much in fed ex cup.Alternately,you could have every tour event represented by its champion or its runnerup.
    • Joel mbuvi ndolo Ndolo  •  Nairobi, Kenya  •  4 months ago
      am shocked, why did she decide to destroy that mansion? such people should be given a chance to go and live in other world like Africa and use the much they have to help those trapped
      in poverty.

    Yahoo! Sports Authors